From Blood and Ash (Blood and Ash, #1)

Readers overwhelmingly found From Blood and Ash (Blood and Ash, #1) immersive, emotionally intense, and difficult to put down, with many praising it as a standout romantasy read. Its dark, mysterious world, layered mythology, political intrigue, and supernatural atmosphere made a strong impression, while Poppy was frequently celebrated as a compelling, brave, and rebellious heroine. The chemistry and banter between Poppy and Hawke were among the most commonly praised elements, complemented by well-received supporting characters and sensual scenes.

The main criticism concerns the pacing: some readers found the opening slow, dense, or confusing, particularly while they were learning the world and its rules, and a few felt the book was overlong or repetitive. Opinions also varied on how predictable the revelations were, with experienced fantasy readers sometimes anticipating them. Overall, the book seems best suited to readers who enjoy slow-burn romance, high emotional stakes, dramatic fantasy, and richly built worlds, especially those willing to give it time to gather momentum.